There’s been a lot of buzz lately about AI diminishing our ability to think critically. A recent study suggested that relying on AI too much can make us disengage, leading to weaker problem-solving skills.

And on the surface, that sounds like a real concern. If we offload thinking to AI, wouldn’t that mean we’re thinking less?

But in reality, AI doesn’t kill critical thinking—it shifts where we apply it.

AI in UX: Critical Thinking in a New Role

Let’s start with my field—UX design.

AI tools are becoming increasingly capable, helping with everything from automating usability testing to generating design variations in seconds. Some might say that reduces the need for deep thinking, but I’d argue it actually enhances it.

• When I use AI to summarize user research, I still have to determine which insights are relevant and how to apply them.
• When AI generates wireframes or UI elements, I have to critically evaluate whether the output aligns with user needs and business goals.
• When I create content strategies with AI, I have to decide what messaging best resonates with the audience.

AI speeds up execution, but it doesn’t remove decision-making, problem-solving, or strategic thinking—if anything, it allows me to focus on them more.

AI in Everyday Life: Where Critical Thinking Still Thrives

But let’s step outside UX and talk about life in general. AI is creeping into every part of our daily routines—do we really use it in a way that discourages critical thought?

Here are a few examples from my own life:

1. Financial Planning – I use AI to analyze market trends and optimize investments, but I still have to interpret the data, weigh risks, and make strategic decisions. AI gives insights; it doesn’t decide what’s best for my family’s financial future.
2. Gaming & Strategy – I love gaming, and whether it’s D&D, strategy games, or classic RPGs, these all require adaptation, planning, and tactical thinking. AI-generated hints or strategies can help, but in the end, I’m the one making choices and dealing with the consequences.
3. Faith & Theological Discussions – AI can summarize theological arguments, but Bible study requires reflection, interpretation, and debate. AI might provide a starting point, but spiritual growth comes from grappling with ideas, discussing with others, and applying insights to life.
4. Business & Leadership – Running Create Ape, I often use AI for research, proposal drafts, and competitor analysis. But that doesn’t replace strategic thinking, decision-making, and understanding human dynamics—it just removes the busywork.

The Real Issue: Passive vs. Active Engagement with AI

The real danger isn’t AI itself—it’s how we interact with it. If we blindly accept AI-generated outputs without questioning them, that’s when critical thinking suffers.

But if we treat AI as an assistant, not a decision-maker, we can actually enhance our cognitive abilities:

• AI removes friction from tedious tasks, freeing up more time for deep thinking.
• AI accelerates ideation, allowing us to refine and debate ideas faster.
• AI challenges our biases by presenting alternative viewpoints, prompting deeper analysis.

If anything, we’re using critical thinking more—just in different ways.

So, Is AI Making Us Dumber?

No. But mindless reliance on AI can.

The key isn’t rejecting AI but using it intentionally—as a tool that supports decision-making, strategy, and problem-solving rather than replacing them.

I’d love to hear your thoughts—how do you use AI in your work and life? Do you feel like it strengthens or weakens your ability to think critically?

‍